Antisemitism in the UK

This is from the Guardian (today’s newsletter).

'Jewish people make up 0.5% of the UK population and many at the moment feel vulnerable, targeted and alone, Rich tells me. Add to that their sense that the response to recent antisemitic hate incidents has been muted, and many Jewish people say it leaves them with the feeling that others simply do not care that Jews are being targeted.

'In particular, Rich highlighted antisemitism among those one would expect to be allies of minorities, people who would otherwise consider themselves progressive liberals, pointing out that too often legitimate criticism of Israel slips into hatred of Jews in the diaspora.

'“The 76-year-old Jewish man who was stabbed in Golders Green, he’s not a serving IDF soldier,” Rich says. “It’s ridiculous. There is an atmosphere of legitimised hatred – not criticism, not opposition, but hatred – towards Israel, not as a state and a government but as a nation and people, that has developed and taken root in liberal opinion and left-wing opinion. This atmosphere of hatred by definition is uncontrollable and generates more hatred and more attacks. And it slips very, very easily from hatred of Israel to hatred of Israelis to hatred of Jews.”

'Rich also identifies a particular issue with antisemitism among a small portion of British Muslim society, which must be delicately addressed. No doubt it helps that several leading British imams have condemned the Golders Green attack and expressed their solidarity with the Jewish community.

'“If you look at opinion polling … in Britain and in other countries, it consistently shows that levels of antisemitism are higher, significantly higher, among Muslim communities than they are in the population as a whole,” says Rich. “I have to stress, not most Muslims. And also not most of the antisemitism in society … but it’s far too high.

‘“People are very nervous about raising this issue,” says Rich, and he is keen to stress that “there are genuine sensitivities because anti-Muslim prejudice is a real problem as well in this country, and there are extremist voices on the far right who will always try to exploit these issues”. But he argues the perception of this problem is inflated by avoiding it: “One of the ways that enables the far right to do that is if there is a vacuum because no one else is talking about these issues in an evidenced and measured and constructive way.” Rich points to a rise in antisemitic sermons in some UK mosques after the 7 October massacre in Israel by Hamas, and the subsequent war in Gaza.’

(End of extract)

I know there has always been an undercurrent of antisemitism in Britain.

Since the Hamas attack, however, and the Israeli response, antisemitism seems to have become legitimised among a lot of the UK population.

Part of the evidence for this (apart from the string of attacks directly against Jewish people and their property, including ambulances) are the acquittals for attacks on Jewish businesses; acquittals for direct action in support of Palestine; acquittals for showing support to proscribed organisations.

No wonder a lot of young Jewish people are saying the UK is not a safe place to bring up their families.

3 Likes

If there’s one thing I’m “anti-”, it’s being anti any group of people based on their ethnicity, religion or anything else other than their actions.

There’s too much anti- in the world and not enough pro-.

But 'twas ever thus, it being human nature to hate the tribe from over the hill.

11 Likes

There’s a sort of tribalism that is normal (I’m not saying it’s good), for example the way that people on the left/right will rush to defend those of a similar bent.

But that’s a lot different to the creation of an atmosphere in the UK which leads the Joint Terrorism Analysis Centre to raise the threat level to “severe” (for the first time since November 2021).

1 Like

People forget that this sort of racial hatred and attacks also happened in the 70’s - the target at that time were asians and black ethnic minorities - at that time these reactions had a lot to do with Enoch Powell’s speech - clear parallels with the rhetroic put out by the Reform party and the government’s decision to outlaw the Palestine Action group. There is confusion with respect to antisemitism and anti-zionisism which does not help. Last night’s BBC question time was very good - it illustrated Reform’s thinking clearly. The Green Party’s co-leader Emma Reynolds was also impressive - though the Greens also have their own problems

2 Likes

Not least having one deputy leader who can’t be allowed to speak to the press and a leader who used the incident as an opportunity to attack the police!

1 Like

I heard a rather amusing comment from a chap on a call in to LBC this morning discussing whatever it was said by Zack Polanski. The caller said Green membership has totally changed. He said it used to be all women named Tabitha who cared about the environment, now it’s aggressive activists. Ha Ha! Call me Tabitha.

4 Likes

Oddly enough, I know numerous British people who are also from Jewish heritage, mostly not actively practicing. Names that wouldn’t remotely identify, like Green. Not short of a bob or three, I don’t see them being remotely worried about their safety in UK now.

Interestingly, one family who switched from Sephardic to CofE a few generations ago to circumvent social prejudices when purchasing their baronetcy, now have a scion married to the daughter of our current queen (by an earlier marriage). If antisemitism is making life unpleasant for Jewish People in Britain, it seems not to be so across the board.

I was worried about my lovely nephew, who works in the City and carries his father’s very traditional Jewish name. He says everything is fine. His Austrian wife and beautiful children would be in Vienna with her parents if there was real danger in London.

The News exaggerates and possibly some bad actors are stirring up hatred with intent.

7 Likes

`But names like that do, eg Philip Green - in the rag trade.

Ancestrally I am told I am Jewish, but I am not.

Religion was man’s attempt to justify its existence. If I am pushed I am a humanist, we all need to exist together.

All this hatred is just « my version is better than yours ». For fuck sake just accept that we are on this earth, none of us are more deserving and that applies to all!

No I will not apologise for my language!

4 Likes

An example of hatred.

Unfortunately, it would seem that there are a lot of Israelis who would not agree with that sentiment.
It is not their nationality, nor how they worship, or even how they dress, but what they do that sets others against them.

6 Likes

Quod erat demonstrandum.

I agree with all you said, where I live people are just getting on with their lives and asking friends and family that live and work in busy cities they say the same. People are far more concerned with the government, the, perceived, problems with politicians and on a more local level, useless, clueless councillors.

1 Like

And Stephen Christopher Yaxley-Lennon would say something else.

I doubt that your assessment is of much comfort to the Jews of Golders Green, or of the other less prosperous areas of the UK! Rich people like your friends have always been insulated, quite naturally, from the real world.

2 Likes

I’d ask those who say antisemitism Isn’t really a problem —- would you also like to say Islamophobia isn’t really a problem?

And if you wouldn’t, does that perhaps reveal something about your thinking?

3 Likes

Oh what comfort you live in, all jews are rich. Now where have I read that from? Late 1930s?
Religion, or heritage is IRRELEVANT, it is the person not anything else that defines them.

@Gordian_nut , I recall from one of @Susannah ‘s previous posts that she is considerably better off than most of us: I think her point of view comes from mixing with rich people rather than thinking all Jewish people are rich!

It is probably true, we all are a product of our culture, lifestyle and experiences. Doesn’t make any one opinion right or any one superior. Life’s rich tapestry.

1 Like

May be I got her wrong? I am better off than most but it has nothing to do with my ancestry or inheritance, £50 when I was 14.

Division based on religion has caused hatred, death, wars…

I hate the fact that persons are judged based on heritage not who they are.

1 Like