Form France Individual - practical experiences

Hi Pierre

@Helenochka has kindly replied to your questions about the HMRC address, and the location on the FFI for the Impôts stamp and signature. You enter details of your pension payment in section C2, including the PSTR (under payers reference). I would add in your banking details on the last page (even though they don’t ask for them!), highlighting that you have had tax withheld,. I would attach evidence of the tax withheld to speed things up..For completeness you could specifically request an NT/No Tax PAYE code to be issued, even though presumably no further payments will be made.

Best of luck. Let us know how you get on..

Oooh, you’ve got my braincell sparking! Absolutely, why would you request an NT code for an empty pension - unless you intend to top it up again…

So, I ponder where would that sit in the prelevement forfaiture rules. Because all existing rights have been extinguished - no future ones (at present) - no requirement under the rules that the pension fund is to be closed.

Practical application - cash in a small pension pot. Standard 20% rule. IF it’s not automatically closed by the provider, get the NT code, transfer in your large pot and then fully cash that in, with the NT code in place.

What might the Impot argue here… ?

They wouldn’t argue they would just tax you on any later withdrawal according to your total income in the French tax year into which it fell. The 7.5% concessionary rate is for first withdrawal only.

This is why to keep access to the French 7.5% rate you can’t do the usual trick to avoid the massive grab of emergency tax by hmrc by doing a token first withdrawal of £1 or whatever the fund administrators will let you geet away with ss a minimum - cos then the withdrawal of the rest becomes a second withdrawal from the fund so loses right to 7.5% from France.

I’m not totally certain the French don’t also say the whole fund must be taken too on the 7.5% withdrawal.

If your scheme would work though the UK won’t have deducted emergency tax on later withdrawals which is a good thing… however on reflection you do need the NT tax code on the fund otherwise for later withdrawals the provideer would be obliged to deduct the stsndard rate of tax (about 20%) from the later withdrawals if it didn’t hsve a tax code. (You are then meant to sort out refund or paying more at end of year on your uk tax return if you are uk resident otherwise you’d have to specifically claim it back). But actually first withdrawal from any fund triggers HMRC to issue a tax code on the fund apparently within a theoretical two weeks or so and you just want to make sure this is an NT code.

I am not sn expert but this is how it looks.

Like Karen, I suspect the Fisc would take the view that only the first withdrawal qualifies for the 7.5% tax rate. You’d probably get hammered on the second (large) withdrawal.
But hey, give it a go and let us know!

As you know, there was a discussion on this subject some time back although I don’t think this particular idea came up at the time Tax ruling on taking 2 pension lump sums/7.5% tax rate

A characterically creative suggestion from @larkswood12…

I agree with @Helenochka that the Impôts will not accept two bites at the same cherry (ie two tax favoured lump sums from the same plan). The only exception would theoretically be if lump sum 1 was a “hardship” type withdrawal (eg closure of business, divorce etc), which seems v unlikely to apply here.

Secondly HMRC would be deeply unimpressed at what is an attempt to recycle an NT code originally awarded for (the smaller) plan 1 to apply against - in substance - another plan’s funds.This is even assuming a) plan 1 was still open and b) the pension company would be prepared to apply the existing NT code against the funds introduced from plan 2. HMRC grants NT codes on a specific pension plan/consideration of the tax treaty position on a case by case basis only, not on a ‘blanket’ going forward basis.

Boring best advice - take the cash flow hit on the PAYE emergency code for the larger plan 2 lump sum, and seek a UK refund the conventional way via form FFI..

Thank you @Helenochka. So sorry I missed this. Tired and I get quite disabled by administrative tasks. Tough for a French man!

Thanks @George1. Useful advice, an NT/No Tax PAYE code could be useful as I expect to receive soon my national pension in the UK. Will come back to you with updates.

Two things..1. Your state pension (assuming this is your “national pension”) is paid gross, always. So you wouldn’t need an NT code..2. Although academic due to 1. you’ll see from my post above, an NT code is granted by HMRC to apply against a specific pension and isn’t transferable to any other pensions you may be receiving.

1 Like

You have my sympathy, Pierre. Modern life can be surprisingly exhausting given that all this technology we have is supposed to make it easier.

Re getting an NT code, I wonder would it be worth waiting until you start receiving your UK state pension before cashing in your personal pension. To avoid having to submit a second “France Individual” form for this new source of income.

I believe you can list several sources of income in a single form, so if you could include both the personal pension withdrawal AND the UK state pension, it would be less hassle for you.

Can someone more knowledgeable confirm whether this is possible?

On another subject, once the state pension pushes us into tax-paying territory, presumably the new workaround for UK state pensioners for whom the state pension is their only source of income won’t work so easily for people who live abroad? HMRC will surely require proof that they have no other source of income.

1 Like

Yes, you can include more than 1 pension in an FFI - for convenience. As mentioned above, no NT code is actually needed for the UK state pension, but including it in the FFI means HMRC is made fully aware of the quantum of pensions being received. They can then confirm that both state pension and any private pensions in the FFI are exempt from UK tax under the tax treaty, for French tax residents.

1 Like

France Individual DT form filled and sent to the “Centre des Impots” via the online ‘messagerie’ selecting in the Subject menu “Demande de Documents” and “Attestation de recidence”. Now :crossed_fingers: it comes back quickly.