From the river to the sea.,

NYT written letter by the founder of World Central Kitchen:

In the worst conditions you can imagine — after hurricanes, earthquakes, bombs and gunfire — the best of humanity shows up. Not once or twice but always.

The seven people killed on a World Central Kitchen mission in Gaza on Monday were the best of humanity. They are not faceless or nameless. They are not generic aid workers or collateral damage in war.

Saifeddin Issam Ayad Abutaha, John Chapman, Jacob Flickinger, Zomi Frankcom, James Henderson, James Kirby and Damian Sobol risked everything for the most fundamentally human activity: to share our food with others.

These are people I served alongside in Ukraine, Turkey, Morocco, the Bahamas, Indonesia, Mexico, Gaza and Israel. They were far more than heroes.

Their work was based on the simple belief that food is a universal human right. It is not conditional on being good or bad, rich or poor, left or right. We do not ask what religion you belong to. We just ask how many meals you need.

From Day 1, we have fed Israelis as well as Palestinians. Across Israel, we have served more than 1.75 million hot meals. We have fed families displaced by Hezbollah rockets in the north. We have fed grieving families from the south. We delivered meals to the hospitals where hostages were reunited with their families. We have called consistently, repeatedly and passionately for the release of all the hostages.

All the while, we have communicated extensively with Israeli military and civilian officials. At the same time, we have worked closely with community leaders in Gaza, as well as Arab nations in the region. There is no way to bring a ship full of food to Gaza without doing so.

That’s how we served more than 43 million meals in Gaza, preparing hot food in 68 community kitchens where Palestinians are feeding Palestinians.

We know Israelis. Israelis, in their heart of hearts, know that food is not a weapon of war.

Israel is better than the way this war is being waged. It is better than blocking food and medicine to civilians. It is better than killing aid workers who had coordinated their movements with the Israel Defense Forces.

The Israeli government needs to open more land routes for food and medicine today. It needs to stop killing civilians and aid workers today. It needs to start the long journey to peace today.

In the worst conditions, after the worst terrorist attack in its history, it’s time for the best of Israel to show up. You cannot save the hostages by bombing every building in Gaza. You cannot win this war by starving an entire population.

We welcome the government’s promise of an investigation into how and why members of our World Central Kitchen family were killed. That investigation needs to start at the top, not just the bottom.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said of the Israeli killings of our team, “It happens in war.” It was a direct attack on clearly marked vehicles whose movements were known by the Israel Defense Forces.

It was also the direct result of a policy that squeezed humanitarian aid to desperate levels. Our team was en route from a delivery of almost 400 tons of aid by sea — our second shipment, funded by the United Arab Emirates, supported by Cyprus and with clearance from the Israel Defense Forces.

The team members put their lives at risk precisely because this food aid is so rare and desperately needed. According to the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification global initiative, half the population of Gaza — 1.1. million people — faces the imminent risk of famine. The team would not have made the journey if there were enough food, traveling by truck across land, to feed the people of Gaza.

The peoples of the Mediterranean and Middle East, regardless of ethnicity and religion, share a culture that values food as a powerful statement of humanity and hospitality — of our shared hope for a better tomorrow.

There’s a reason, at this special time of year, Christians make Easter eggs, Muslims eat an egg at iftar dinners and an egg sits on the Seder plate. This symbol of life and hope reborn in spring extends across religions and cultures.

I have been a stranger at Seder dinners. I have heard the ancient Passover stories about being a stranger in the land of Egypt, the commandment to remember — with a feast before you — that the children of Israel were once slaves.

It is not a sign of weakness to feed strangers; it is a sign of strength. The people of Israel need to remember, at this darkest hour, what strength truly looks like.

3 Likes

What if no aid or food gets delivered in Gaza?

Was this the plan?

A part of it.

If you can remove aid going in, remove ‘difficult’ reporters, prevent other forms of communication with the outside world, then it won’t be long before the Palestinian problem is solved and the land is free to occupy while keeping your ally governments on board.

Forgiveness is always easier to obtain than permission.

5 Likes

That’s about the long and short of it AM. Though Israeli arrogance, allowed to fester by the West since '67 at least, may yet be their undoing.

I love the way Netanyahu and the iDF are saying it was a “mistake”. It was a mistake, but not in the execution, that was deliberate, they now believe it was a mistake because they have caused more international outrage than they expected.

Quite so. And the IDF’s faux outrage about hostages is disgusting since they have already demonstrated exactly how much value they really place on hostages’ lives by shooting dead those 3 young men who escaped a couple of months ago.

1 Like

Why did World Central Kitchen need 2 former Royal Marines and a former Army sharpshooter in Gaza?

Arguably because it’s a dangerous place, as amply demonstrated by events.

1 Like

For their own security. It’s a dangerous place.

1 Like

I must admit, that was my thought.

Of course it’s a dangerous place, but does that mean a charity was being escorted by three armed ex-soldiers? If they were unarmed, they’d hardly have been much use.

This sounds cynical. Ex forces are not solely defined by their military experience.

As Mr Andrés said in his letter above -

“In the worst conditions you can imagine — after hurricanes, earthquakes, bombs and gunfire — the best of humanity shows up. Not once or twice but always.”

Even unarmed, their training and experience would be of immense help in a war zone. They were volunteers. Why does anyone volunteer? Because they feel as humans they must. Seems churlish to impugn the motives of those braver than ourselves who have lost their lives.

4 Likes

They were described earlier as security advisors on the BBC site. While there may have been ‘additional’ duties, I could imagine they were there to help prevent exactly this kind of thing from happening through giving the IDF the right kind of intel and communications.

2 Likes

source

1 Like

Unless they’re there explicitly as “security advisers”, there solely for their military experience!

The army imparts extremely thorough training to enable personnel to operate successfully under pressure and quickly evaluate circumstances in order to make rapid independent decisions in very dangerous, complex situations. In civilian education parlance these fall under the umbrella of ‘transferable skills’. Two of the best Masters students I ever had the pleasure of working with (‘teaching’ is the wrong word) were former soldiers.

2 Likes

So - in effect - they would (need to be) “in charge” of the convoy and making all the decisions?

Getting out of my depth here, but I imagine their mission would have been directed by and conducted through their central control unit, while having the experience to respond to immediate emergencies on the ground.

1 Like

One would have thought that the locals could have arranged ground security for such NGO personnel.

Not that anyone who didn’t have comprehensive Patriot/AEGIS coverage could have prevented a drone strike.

Hahahahahaha
No, you get ground security from locals if local populations can sustain it, which they prob can’t, and if there isn’t a vastly superior force intent on blasting you to bits. I can remember being shot at in the 80’s when I worked for an NGO and there’s not much anyone on the ground can do to help especially if you don’t have body armour, and I read in the Grauniad that the Israelis don’t let NGO workers have any on when they are in the Gaza Strip.

2 Likes

The IDF have been killing local police for a long time now.