Seed oils and other things, the studies behind them

As bad as the cash only money laundering car washes staffed by dubious people. Constantly flushing car wash water down std drains where real companies re use the water after filtering.

That’s tosh, if you don’t mind me saying.

There is much less chronic ill health than there used to be, overall we are not only living longer but more people are reaching old age in a fit enough state of health to enjoy it.

That’s a complex one. I’m not sure I can do it justice in a couple of sentences.

Modern medical treatments tend to be expensive. Consider the drug Tepotinib used for certain types of lung cancer. A friend’s father was prescribed it which is how I know about it. A month’s supply costs Ā£7200 (nominal NHS price given in the BNF). If you have the right sort of lung cancer it will give you a roughly 50:50 chance of keeping your cancer from getting worse for an average of 11 months.

Are you going to say to someone ā€œI have a drug that will keep you alive a year, but you can’t have itā€?

If your interpretation of keeping someone with lung cancer going another year is ā€œkeeping people sick so pharma can profitā€ then I’m not sure how I argue you out of that.

Sadly we won’t be able to run the experiment and find out. I suspect they make a small contribution - but that’s it, small. Studies such as this one do show an increased risk but involve significantly above average exposure.

We’re getting better at diagnosing and treating stuff which is a big contributor to numbers going up. But, yes, there’s a lot of concern about increase in cancer incidence in the under 50’s

2 Likes

Children are of course the biggest environmental issue.

1 Like

TBH I’d be far more worried about environment oestrogens and the effect they have on fertility, personal sense of gender identity and some kinds of cancer, not to mention environmental disruption. A fair amount probably comes through human use of the oral contraceptive.

Agreed.

So do I. :+1:
A study shows a causal path. Good. :+1:

No, it is not provably small.
It is you have just said your suspicion.
I have the same suspicion: there seems to be some evidence of a credible link.

Saying the effect is small, is not an excuse for failing to offer proof of the effect in normal exposure.

I am certainly not saying there is no effect. I am saying the effect is not proven.

:+1:

1 Like

Not an issue for me.

Ageist comment!
People are the biggest environmental issue, surely? :grinning_face:

Data from England and Wales revealed that while dementia incidence fell by 28.8% between 2002 and 2008, it subsequently increased by 25.2% between 2008 and 2016, with disparities widening among those with lower educational attainment.

Global diabetes prevalence has more than doubled over the past three decades,

You are free to comment as it’s a discussion point.

Eliminate children and after 100 years humans stop being an environmental problem (other than what they left behind). I don’t really agree, but can see the POV.

Who’s going to pay mine and Billy’s pension :joy:

1 Like

Caused by wide-spread public uptake of the internet, facebook and living online. :wink:

1 Like

This particular health problem is linked to obesity though isn’t it - and we are getting more obese because a US style diet is terrible and it is spreading globally as developing nations become wealthier.

But this isn’t faffing with micro-nutrients or worrying that seed oils are bad for you - it is, plain and simple, too many calories and too little exercise.

ā€œEnvironmental problemā€?
We are concerned (mostly, and in this conversation) because the environment is becoming less friendly to us.
Yep. No more kids and the world will gradually become more environmentally friendly for kids.

But don’t blame kids: none of them asked to be here! :wink:

That’s tosh if you don’t mind me saying so :joy:
Well partly true but the constituents of sugar, more sugar and yet more high fructose corn starch and maltodextrine and other Hidden sugars is driving insulin resistance which is a hormone upset affecting so many parts of the body.

TouchƩ :slight_smile:

OK I was slightly oversimplifying but - I am sure you would agree - modern preprocessed and fast foods pack too many calories into a format which (whatever you believe the mechanism to be) leaves you wanting more very quickly.

I’d get worried about that way before I got worried about PFAs or whether seed oils are bad for you per se (probably not TBH) or just because of the calories they bring to the equation.

2 Likes

Yes agreed, although it’s my N=1 experiment, eating carbohydrate from junk food does exactly as you say, keep you hungry every couple of hours which increases the overall calorie intake. Couple that with the insulin spikes and it blocks fat burning for energy and switches to fat storage due to the carbohydrate overload. Switching to real food, possibly vegetarian intake of whole foods and the body can adapt so fat storage is not triggered. Probably down to some gut bacteria as well. It’s multifactorial but at the centre is factory food.

Not at all. We already exist for better or worse, and so do our children, grandchildren, etc etc. It’s a fact, not an ageist comment.

But the worst thing anyone can do in terms of environmental burden is have a/another/more children. I can sort my rubbish, refuse to travel on planes, eat nothing but home grown beans sprouts but that is minuscule when compared to another human on the planet

Kids do not choose to be born

100% :grinning_face:

I’m astonished.

The race would die out – unless you outsource your responsibilities to others who are having children.

I don’t share that view. Optimism means having faith in future generations. Humanity has faced many crises and has always come through them.