A Jewish joke with a predictable Jewish punch line IMO!
Four Rabbis are in the habit of taking long walks together in the countryside. Being Rabbis, they get to talking about obscure points of Jewish theology. It usually becomes an argument, three against one, with the same rabbi always arguing against the other three. And then one of the other three will shrug and say: “That’s it, it’s three against one. Therefore, we’re right, you’re wrong. End of discussion.”
Naturally, the fourth rabbi starts getting a little tired of this.
It happens again. They’re walking and talking, and it becomes an argument, and it’s three against one again, and it’s the same odd-man-out as always. And as always, they say to him: “That’s it, it’s three against one. Therefore, we’re right, you’re wrong. End of discussion.”
And the fourth rabbi starts to pray. He says, “Dear God, you know I don’t ask you for much. But I put up with this all the time, and this time, this time, I know I’m right! Please, God, show them a sign, so that they may see the error of their ways.”
And no sooner does he say that… when, out of a cloudless blue sky, a white cloud appears, right above where the rabbits are walking! The fourth rabbi says: “Don’t you see, it’s a sign! God is telling you to listen to me!” The other rabbis shrug it off as a natural phenomenon.
The fourth rabbi prays even more fervently. “Dear God, do you see what idiots I have to put up with?? I beg you, give a sign that even they will understand.”. And no sooner does he say that… when the white cloud suddenly turns black, and a lightning bolt comes out of it, striking a tree near where the rabbis are walking. The fourth rabbi says: “It’s a sign! God wants you to listen to me!” The other rabbis shrug it off as a natural phenomenon.
The fourth rabbi starts to pray again… but before he can say anything, the black cloud parts, a beam of light comes down, and a booming voice says: “LISTEN TO HIM. HE’S RIGHT.”
The fourth rabbi glares at the others. “Well???”
One of the rabbis shrugs and says: “So now it’s three against two.”