PM Theresa May says there will be no attempt to remain inside EU

HIlary, Any sensible person will recognise Farage for the duplicitous creep he is. It's actually not worth discussing people like him, Gove and his mummy (AKA wife). These are evil egotists who have risked the wellbeing of millions for no definable upside. Meanwhile the UK evonomy continues falter.

Tim, I agree with your take. I think as the difficulties emerge and Fox and Davis founder, Brexit will will be "finessed" into something that makes sense (i.e. dumped). I just hope Europe gives enough rope for that to happen.

Hilary, I think it was abundantly clear at the time that the government wanted to take us into the Common Market, and it was also entirely clear that there was an under-agenda that it would eventually lead to closer unification of the European countries. UK government is parliamentary democracy, not an individually representative system. So we elect our government to do what they say they’ll do, and elect the opposition to power if we don’t want them to do it. Referendums have no place in this; most governments know this well and go out of their way to avoid any suggestion of referendum on any topic, however important to the country, because it always results in a bizarre and unsatisfactory outcome. Cameron was a fool for being trapped into offering one and did the right thing eventually when it all went pear-shaped. He should have acted more decisively at the right time.

It is abundantly clear that the result of the referendum was, as Tim says, a shot across the government’s bows made by a ‘majority’ of people who just wanted to smack them, not actually withdraw. Lots of evidence for this. However, we are where we are and it’s now the gov’ts job to negotiate a best possible Leave position and then consider whether what they achieve is in the best interests of the country. It is the opposition’s job to oppose their recommendation and put an/the alternative as their policy, and a general election should then be held to decide the matter. It should emphatically NOT go to another referendum.

Farage only gained support by appealing to ignorant people who could not see past his lies and scaremongering about immigration, not because they wanted a direct voice on the matter overall at a higher level. He massively increased racist feeling throughout the country with catastrophic effects. Racism has never been far below the surface in Britain for thousands of years and is far too easily re-ignited by evil-doers. There were certainly, however, a very large number of people who believed the country is best Out for more intelligent reasons. Most probably not a majority though, given the absolutely huge benefit the UK people have received through being In.

Not sure why you should be surprised at so little being said here about the labour party - it’s off topic.

It is extraordinarily hard to see any way that the UK could possibly be as prosperous outside the EU, as In, never mind more so, and even if it might eventually happen we’ll have had decades of financial hardship, abandonment of the many beneficial EU regulations and programmes and we’ll become subject to increasing US-led acceptance of dangerous activity by big business – the TTIP, relatively unregulated chemicals in our agriculture, pharmaceuticals and food and a host of panic measures to try to resurrect some acceptable quality of life. The NHS, pensions, full-ish employment, education, disadvantaged areas and industries, all under massive threat. And it can’t stop immigration anyway. Being able to travel without passports and documentation is a worthwhile – indeed valuable – right for the people of a civilised society and is to be sought. Not at all foolhardy. Not to be rushed, however, as the EU has tried, which may have been foolish. Our psychological health comes way second to our need for enough money to live on, and we lost our ability to plot our own course a long time before the EU, or the Common Market, or the Council of Europe, or anything else in the last century or more. It cannot come back - Britain’s days as a world power are over, and the world is the better for it.

I do hope he doesn't do anything silly while he's in charge ...

Careful Vero, one " creepy crony in his (N F) party" to quote you, is Douglas Carswell, yes he's tall, thin and has a strange bone structure face - he is also my MP. I first met him when I was the local Community Centre Office Administrator and he'd just been elected as the local Tory MP. Sadly he changed party when Labour was in office, I was in France when he changed parties and he was and still is apparently a very good Constituencš MP but, like Nigel I presume he didn't like the lack of Democracy in the EC - I'm not defending Farage but I will defend my own MP in UK, he is a man who says what he believes in and acts accordingly in what he sees as best interests of his constituents.

There was an excellent BBC or ITV documentary on tv one night last winter all about Farage - and how much he's worth, how he used his position as an MEP to make as much moneš as he could from the EC, out of being one. He was on the Agriculture and Fisheries EC committee and in 1 year only turned up 6 times! Also he made no secret after BREXIT that getting the UK out of the EU was his motive! He, manipulated, in all sorts of ways and relied on his 'Charisma' to carry the day for the vote.

It wouldnt surprise me, Given TM said no going back on vote, if either Carswell, leaves UKIP, returns to the Tories or joins Lib Dems or potential new party at some time in next 4-5 years! I think it will depend on how the BREXIT negotiations will go and the financial impact on the UK in terms of job losses and economy. Finallš I like and agree with all your comments on Farage himself, plus what I learnt about him in that documentary. As for Carswell ,he gets interviewed a lot just before and after the UKIP campaign, on regional as well as less so on mainstream UK TV programmes, so I do hear a lot of what he says that you may not be aware of.

Hilary Jane, have you seen the exchange rate today?

Appalling. It continues to fall and I would like you to tell us all who depend on pension income just how long a period of adjustment you consider acceptable?

We may have to move because our income is being so depleted and there is a distinct possibility that we may need to release equity in our property in order to have a decent standard of living.

We are British citizens even though we are not living within the UK and your post only mentions some monetary disadvantage, which is far from the truth for those living on UK based pensions.

Although we are here concerned with France, this problem affects UK retirees all over the EU, many millions of people.

This monetary disadvantage you speak of will most affect those on already small incomes, which I suppose they will be too happy about.

Valerie, he should feel at home. Don't they call this time of the year the silly season!

And all this disruption for no valid reason at all Jane. A self inflicted wound to the British economy.

Jane, it is much, much worse than that. The damage already done to the UK economy by Brexit is quite profound.

But the key point is that this devaluation, which will probably get larger, has a very negative impact on UK EXPORTS unlike previously.
I quote from a financial report "In theory, a weaker currency should also boost net trade in Britain, but the increasing relative importance of imports in the British economy means that the overall effect won’t be as salutary this time around.
In 1992, 45% of domestic goods sectors sourced between 80 and 100% of their materials from the U.K.
By 2011, that proportion had fallen to just 15% (and I think has got worse since then).
So a weaker pound will actually raise input costs for exporters, making a falling currency less of a boon for competitiveness than it might have been decades ago."
The impact on consumer prices will become evident early in 2017 as any forward purchasing contracts unwind.
We know that companies have been delaying or cutting back on investments and hiring and that coupled with the the decline in the value of the pound will probably lead to a recession in the second half of 2016 and an actual decline in GDP during 2017. Companies are also being hit by the decline in bond yields as that means they need to put more cash aside to find the pension gap which in turn leads to reduced investment, jobs and eventually having a further negative effect on consumer spending.
As the UK economy goes in to decline, Osborn’s comment about cutting back on the so called triple lock for state pensions will seem almost too mild compared to the “austerity package” that the UK will need to put in place.
All of this was forecast and through incompetence the Remain campaign failed to get the message across and were simply not believed. Many of my friends around the world have described it as an act of collective suicide.
But whatever, the deed is done, we have left the EU and there is no way back.
So Jane, the answer to your question is quite simple, pending the final discussions with the EU which 2019 is an absurdly early date, there will be a prolonged period of uncertainty. That means that companies where they have a choice and they see better margins, greater flexibility, will invest in the EU further leading to a relative long term decline in the UK economy with all the consequent loss of jobs, decreaed Gov't spending etc.
Austerity MAX, in fact.
I anticipate that at nest the £/€ rate will approach parity by the end of the year. My advice is plan your expenditure on that basis.
You may well ask why do I assert that the deal with the EU will take longer than just a few years. Well that is another topic but simply put, the talk is about tariffs but they are inconsequential to the real problem.
In order to reach a TRADE deal, each country (or group of countries) will have its own set of "red lines" as indeed will the UK and reconciling those takes a lot of time. Simple example. Let us say the French will want preferential treatment for their wine exports to the UK. The UK might want prefential treatment for well lets say Welsh lamb. But the Spanish will say, well we want special treatment for our Olive oil exports to the UK and if we get that deal we will continue to look after your expats in Spain. Greece will say we want preferntial treatment for our Olive exports and we don't want any Welsh Lamb under any circumstances.

These conflicting requirements, of which the above is just an example will have to be resolved.

Now multiply this trivial example by 27 countries in the EU and by the thousands of product categories and you cna see why trade deals take decades. That the UK and EU will do a deal is certain but the end result after all the inevitable compromises will be pretty much what we had before we left the EU. Pay into the budget, free movement of people and accept our rules, regulations and laws, etc

And just to add a little complexity to the mix. The UK does not have a tariff schedule, as it is part of the EU. So in order to trade uner WTO rules we have to create a tariff schedule and get that acccepted by a UNANIMOUS vote by all 140 WTO members. Given that say some countries may want to have a kick at the UK, say Argentina just as a possible example, and you might see why that might not be a trivial task.
And don't forget we don't have any trained and experienced trade negotiators.
Finally, you will notice the reported argumet between Fox and Johnson. They know already the problems and how difficult it will be to remotely approach the "Leave vote promoses", so they are already into the blame game. It's not my fault, its his, etc
The UK has voted itself into a mess, without any thought as the fantasy was leave the EU and sunshine will break through.
Well it won't.

Absolutely. However, I was really asking Hilary Jane who sees Brexit through rose tinted glasses in her opinion how long was this monetary adjustment going to take.

Those with the least income tend to spend more on heating as they do not have the best insulated housing and oil is paid for in dollars.

With regard to Welsh lamb, in fact the biggest market for young UK hill farm lamb is France, which after spending six weeks in France can then be sold as French.

I agree with you but I have given up debating with people who see Brexit as a positive step because of their tendency to stick their fingers in their ears and chant la lala la when faced with facts. (I'm not saying this is what Hilary does, by the way!)

Sorry, I have to disagree with "strong vested interests in his or her own fortunes, (something by the way, that you cannot accuse Farage of)". IMHO, he has been looking after his own interests very well. He finds no problem receiving his very generous salary/pension from an institution he has done nothing except condemn for years. He has reportedly been seen at the German embassy arranging dual nationality, possibly for the children to which they're perfectly entitled, but he campaigned hard for others to in effect lose EU rights knowing his family would be 'all right jack'. Lastly, and the one that makes me seethe, he has hinted for a long time that the House of Lords needs reform and he should be appointed - Lisa Duffy as part of her UKIP campaign asked yesterday why Farage isn't a Lord already and there's even a petition to get him appointed. So, yes, I think Farage belongs to the group that has perhaps been corrupted by the power he's been able to wield, an increasing sense of self-importance and most definitely has vested interests.

I think part of why it has become an exhausting exercise to debate is because there's such a vast difference between people's expectations of what any final exit from the EU should mean - some want out of the single market but others want in, some think the UK would be fine trading under WTO or similar, others are worried about detrimental tariffs, the ongoing 'immigrants' in/out fiasco (recently a German man had the neighbour's dogs set on him and was told to go back home).

When there is no specific target any debate simply becomes an argument and there is still no cohesive plan.

Even the select committee to be appointed to oversee the brexit department is becoming unworkable in its complexity. There are so many different groups to be represented each with their own vision of how brexit should work that even finding a room large enough to accommodate them, let alone work out how to schedule availability for any meetings, is a challenge in itself.

Well actually,Veronique, I do have to admit to doing it once in my my life, when being haranged in a particularly unpleasant encounter with a Head...(whom thankfully, I managed to get away from, by finding a better post elsewhere - and who later met her own 'Nemesis'....which was satisfying to discover) ......

I knew to expect difficulties when taking the descision....I thought that there would probably be a drop in the exchange rate....and that there will be rough waters for possibly a significant period and probably for at least the 2 year brexit period.....I too am living on just a workplace pension and my budget has got tighter and smaller.....My state pension because of the changes to womens state pension qualifying dates, has been postponed twice.....and I wont get it for some time....

I am an optimist and I don't accept that it will be as bad as Peter & John predict....It is still very early days...and there is alot to do which I am sure Theresa May will ensure, that the relevant Brexiteers will be working on (prep), prior to Article 50....

For all your well put argument/facts Peter, there are people whose opinon I have read (as well as members of my extended family in the accounting and business banking profession), who also voted for Brexit, after carefully considering 'the facts'......it is a matter of which facts and how they are interpreted.......To say that we are 'Doomed, all doomed'....with such certainty, just isn't right

Well, Valerie, you wouldn't expect him not to attend the European Parliament having been elected...It's an ideal place to get much needed publicity for the Brexit cause. so I personally don't have a problem with that...after all in terms of the EU he was a turkey voting for xmas.....He wasn't bothered about securing anything long-term there for himself...not interested in 'kowtow'ing to the other member states in what he sees as a place with corrupt and wasteful practices.....(and I think his sometimes 'inflamatory' comments were to help ensure this publicity ....who was it who said there is no such thing as bad publicity ?)

Going for dual nationality (i believe his wife Kirsten is German, I also don't have a problem with and neither do I have a problem with any ex-pats who want to go down that route...although I don't think that it will be a necessary one....There will still be a degree (probably quite alot of movement within Europe for jobs and education as there was in the days before we joined), just not a complete open door policy..

House of Lords , well in time we shall see...but he's probably got more of a legitimate claim to be there than say, Lord Peter Mandelson...?

Not as bad as most of the average passport booth photos.....

Spot on Peter, the stupidity is incredible.

Meanwhile back at the ranch........ the economy tanks.

Hilary, you are hopelessly optimistic :-) I actually hope you're right but my gut, after too many decades in business, tells me otherwise. This is just a leap into the dark and I think when the consequences are understood Boris, Gove, Farage and the others should be held to account. As Blair is now for his blind support of the idiot Bush and his evil neocon pals.

Hilary, you are hopelessly optimistic :-) I actually hope you're right but my gut, after too many decades in business, tells me otherwise. This is just a leap into the dark and I think when the consequences are understood Boris, Gove, Farage and the others should be held to account. As Blair is now for his blind support of the idiot Bush and his evil neocon pals.

"Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it everywhere, diagnosing it incorrectly and applying the wrong remedies. "

Groucho Marx