PM Theresa May says there will be no attempt to remain inside EU

Whatever you think they are our bastion against those who would take our freedoms from us.

I heard you the first time :-)

Jane, I know the internet is heavily censored in China, but I thoughtsince the days of allowing a McDonalds outlet in Moscow, that things had eased up considerably in Russia.....

Blocking/unblocking internet access, really is the test of any regime...I would be happier about Putin and more inclined to trust him, if he would allow free access to international broadcasts....

' what the Parilement has to say'

risible

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jul/20/commons-debate-tony-blair-contempt-of-parliament-motion-chilcot-iraq

(Hitler wanted Finns to close of Stalingrad but Finland refused,

Don't you mean Leningrad?

The UK offer of help for Finland was a pretext to get control of the Swedish Iron ore mines, so it was worthless. Both Sweden and Norway said no because that would have provoked an invasion by Germany and war on Swedish and Norwegian soil. The Germans had their own plans to secure the iron ore but as far as Sweden was concerned this occurred peacefully.

Based on what I've read, after the Winter war the Finns were only obliged to allow free passage for Soviet citizens to Sweden through Province of Petsamo not to build a railway.

What's wrong with dictators Jane? They kept their countries under control until the US screwed it all up. As for the Olympics, it's been a farce for a long time (maybe since '36) now it's all money, drugs and politics.

The fact is you and I know nothing about Putin other than what is fed to us by Western press, the other fact is the merde we are in is US generated not Russia generated.

Well Howard, I'm not sure what we're talking about here but Russia won the second world war for us. We all may watch the Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan but the real heavy lifing was being done by the Russians.

Remember the guy who was poisoned by drinking radioactive tea in a London hotel and Gregory Markov who was poisoned by a ricin injected umbrella on a London bridge.

Dissent is dangerous and Turkey is going down this path. How generous of Erdogan to decide to release 2,000 of those who had been disrespectful of the office of President after the failed coup.

We all know that a benevolent dictatorship is the mst effevtive form of government, but try telling that to the millions who perished under Stalin and Hitler.

Those who cannot tolerate dissent must not themselves be tolerated.

Yes John but Russia was a bigger prize for Hitler. WWII, known as the Great Patriotic Ware is still remembered there and in most other countries of mainland Europe, whereas UK would prefer to treat it as a historical blip.

Hi Howard,

yes I meant Leningrad, sorry.

As for the railway, I heard of it on Swedish TV, a program series made by this man:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herman_Lindqvist_(journalist)

Herman has many critics, him not being always accurate, but I try to find out more about it. It would have made sense, trnasportin the iron ore on train to Sovjet, instead of wintertime through a deep frozen see ( something up to 6 months/year).

Herman is one of the few Swedes that know Finland, him been living in Helsinki/Helsingfors for years. I don't recall any despute about the railway info.

Actually they are bastards not bastions Jane. If you think they give a toss about freedom etc. you are misaken. All they care about is power and pensions :-) NATO is run by NATO for NATO. It is long past it sell by date.

I forgot that both Russia and the US probably owe their eventual victory to Britain winning the battle of Britain. If Britain had been invaded in 1940, the USA would have done a deal with Germany and not prepared for war and Germany would have been able to throw all its resources into was with the Soviet Union.

The referendum was a first step in the process, and I would describe as an indication that a slim majority want the UK govt to look into the greater question of membership.
A referendum is at best a flawed method by which to communicate between a government and populace.

The parameters of the question are too broad, and the outcomes to varied to ever be as simple as "in" or "Out"

The govt job is to now work through the possibilities, working with the true experts in the field and the civil servants in parliament to produce and outline of leaving, and what it will entail in its entirety, and remaining and all that will involve.

This needs to be conducted in a strictly neutral way, with no party politics involved.

Once the mass of evidence and documentation is presented then the different political ideologies can prepare their 'spin' or responses. (for me points lost for lie telling) and then when the next general election comes around they can mount the soap boxes and seek election on the basis of their responses and formulations of policy. Then they can seek election on the mandate.

This will of course require time, but there is no reason to rush what will be forever a history event.

So to my mind brexit is meaningless, until proper and correct process has been followed. Its far to big and far to reaching in the scope of its potential to be decided on an imperfect question and such a slim result

Well the Referendum perhaps could have been avoided altogether, if people had been given a choice about whether to be formally part of the EU a long time ago, instead of politicians taking us there by stealth and methods somewhat sly & underhand, via the Common Market.....but I suppose, at least this way round we are/have voted on the basis of some experience......A lot has been said about David Cameron making a grave mistake by announcing a referendum and how it was a foolish plan to pacify dissenters in his own party, but he had to do it.....Nigel Farage quite rightly in my opinion, gained his support because the British public wanted their say on something so important...The referendum issue would not have gone away....

What amazes me, is that no- one here is discussing the upheaval in the Labour Party and Corbin....who looks as though he might well succeed in remaining.....but it's difficult to see how he can govern or work with the current crop of MP's...or make a good job of being any kind of affective opposition to the Tory's plans for anything.....Is the Labour party going to hell in a hand cart ?....I'll make this a new discussion as it's a bit too far off the track of this current debate.....

I suppose it is irritating (if one doesn't subscribe to the idea that Nigel Farage is some sort of rascist), to hear people who did support him as being described as though they belong to some sort of club of ignoramusses, who cant think for themselves, rather than people who just see things differently ....

I cast no aspersions on supporters of Mr Farage but I simply can't understand what they see in that awful, vulgar man, he seems to me to ooze dodginess the way the Amoco Cadiz oozed crude. He may well be great fun in the pub if you like tired old jokes about women and foreigners but I think he comes over as an utter bounder (like his creepy cronies in his party).

because the discussion is on Ms May? and not Mr Corbyn perhaps?

As to Msr Farage and co, their willingness to lie says more than anything IMO.

And I'd harldy call allowing things to evolve qualifies as 'stealth' the UK has prospered under the common market, there's been job creation, job security and open markets without restrictions.
Much of the claims made by Farage et al played in insecurities and fears, and was a poor form of politicking . We now need open, honest dialog and facts supported by evidence to present to the UK a clear path forward. And Im sorry but this is something that should never ever have been left to politicians from either camp.

i would suggest the wand, unless made up from a sledgehammer, would have little to no real or meaningful impact. he is after all a politician and a 'jobsworth' at the end of the day, and not a terribly good one either.

Tim,

So now you have me confused...so you were in favour of a referendum on the matter ?....

I disagree with your opinion of Farage...but agree that they have been some good aspects of being part of the EU, but these I think, could have been achieved just being part of a continuing Common Market....

The trouble is, we appoint people to 'take action' in one way or another and it's hard for them in that scenario, to not have some sort of 'pet project' underway (to be seen to be earning their considerable paypacket...).....but what looks to be a 'jolly good idea' and possibly 'visionary' to a politician who has been corrupted by doing the job and by now has strong vested interests in his or her own fortunes,(something by the way, that you cannot accuse Farage of) , rather than looking at current obvious problems and into the future....means a potential nightmare for others. Sometimes we should back the 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it'...'things are ticking along fine as they are and we keep our control' side of things.....I'm of the opinion (and I remember thinking this way ages ago, when the option to be checked and get stamps in one's passport, at each countries borders, was sadly done away with) that to not check, control and monitor influx of people seemed utterly foolhardy - and the outcome of not doing this, over time could have and should have been forseen....

I believe that after a period of adjustment, the UK will be just as prosperous outside the EU and maybe even more so and (like the down-trodden partner, in a failing marriage) we are much better off psychologically, by reclaiming the freedom to breathe clean air and plot our own course....even if that will take real effort and time (and some monetary disadvantage) and will not be the easy option.