Russell Brand charged

You are right, I didn’t realise the girls were under 16, even if he didn’t act on it, grooming itself is a criminal act.

Stephen Fry is probably next. His use of the words “child prostitute” seems quite revealing.

Ah okay…understood

So you think it’s not a big deal? Because it’s TV comedians doing it or because it’s girls who are victims?

Maybe it’s time to make facilitating, procuring and encouraging these behaviours a criminal offense also. It may just discourage others from approaching women on behalf of others if they know they could also be charged with aiding and abetting, or something.

I’m not sure that is what Yann is saying. I have some concern that the day after day reporting and the detail and the quantity of the reporting is excessive and verging on the salacious.* And that yet again those who have been targeted by Brand, and by others, are being made a spectacle of and represented as victims when maybe they just want to get on with their lives.

  • (edit) for example, this evening 5 of the 10 most read articles in the Guardian are about Walliams or Brand. I wonder who is doing the reading? I have read nothing but headlines since all of this started. I felt I did not need to know the details of what the women went through - that is just making them go through it yet again.
1 Like

Yes I agree I don’t think that is what Yan is saying and it’s a fair point.

Unfortunately there are many sexual assaults, most won’t make the press because the perpetrator was not famous. And the same can be said about most celebrity news.

Bad news always sells a lot better than good news, but still people don’t want to read/hear about Gaza or Ukraine everyday, so there always has to be something new.

Does the media decide what we consume or does the consumer decide? I am not sure what the answer is to that one.

1 Like

I think it’s the News of the Screws for thinking people.

I would also like to know where the parents were, perhaps they are also reading the newsprint.

What were these girls doing there? There are more deficient people in this than just the abusers.
Start with the celebrity culture itself and the media which promote it, then the audience which sucks it up.

In our village, (I have been told by a neighbour of theirs), an elderly couple with a grown-up family , got together when she was 14 and she got pregnant at that age. He was several years older. The age of consent would have been 15 at the time, as I believe it still is.
AI tells me about The “Romeo and Juliet” Exception:
Which allows a peer-age exception for consensual relationships where the older partner is no more than 5 years older than the minor (provided the minor is at least 13)

Some of the papers are reporting that another male celebrity is also going down the injunction route to prevent publication of something embarrassing.

@Yann

?? Are you answering the right person? Was this meant for me?

I suppose he’ll be named on social media soon then.

Being young girls (or boys - abuse is not limited to one gender). I think the judge in this case was eminently sensible emphasising that people should be free to go where they want, dressed how they want, and not be subject to sexual assault. IT IS NOT THEIR FAULT!

My sex education at school started with telling the girls not to wear tight clothes as “boys” couldn’t help themselves! That was then, and thankfully the world has moved on,

Well AI is wrong. There is no such exception in UK law. Under 16{s can kiss and cuddle each other with it being considered assault, but that’s as far as they can go.

Stephen Fry, the actor well known for being celibate until he met his now husband?

2 Likes

No there isn’t, though it is common in many jurisdictions - perhaps they should be as otherwise an, e.g. 15 year old couple engaging in entirely consensual activity risk prosecution and stigma.

Is 15 too young to engage in sexual activity - probably though France thinks it is OK and Italy sets it at 14 (13 if the partner is less than four years older).

Jane I think you are missing reading what Yann and I have been saying. Neither of us are condoning the actions of the abusers , or the rights of children to be dressed as they are, .what we are saying is that there are plenty of others ..adults, particularly parents who whould have known or should have known what was going on. Kids being seduced is not a recent phenomena . What Yann had the wit to say is that these revelations serve as deflection from the REAL global problems.

I think Shiba phrased it very accurately in her remarks about Kids , ..and particularly girls get flattered by the attention , long before they have developed the strategies to deal with attention. I remain astonished by the credulity of young women who allow themselves to to whisked off to exotic places just to discover that they are now drug mules …

Just bringing this much closer to home . Jimmy Saville was a frequent visitor to Ireland on monster walks organised by the CRC ..a rehabilitation charity fronted by a Lady Goulding . My family had slight peripheral involvement , It was however very well known NOT to allow Saville to be left alone with young kids.

Actually, there is a de facto exception, exercised by Social Services among others, much to my surprise. The Public Interest stage of the CPS Code Test would also be likely to find a prosecution not to be required in certain circumstances.

The examples I am thinking of involved girls under the age of consent and young men of 18.

Another term was “Nelsonian knowledge”.

Unfortunately some young women/girls, it seems, see this as their way to fame and fortune and never consider the consequences of what might happen to them. All driven by today’s social media frenzy for being famous without working hard for it. Growing up I enjoyed seeing Rolf Harris on TV and was thoroughly shocked when his dirty little secrets came out, who knew amongst the normal public? Whilst these two who have come to light recently and are now/possibly in the future being punished, you do have to wonder about the intelligence of their “victims” or was it all about money and fame.

1 Like

4 Likes

Not going to spoil it so soon, 25mins down the road from me.

1 Like

I have a good friend who worked in the film industry who told me years ago about Brand. Many women, who were in a position to do so, avoided him like the plague.
These men have a great deal of power and have been enabled to behave in this way. Why would a young woman being told she can meet Brand back-stage expect that he’s going to force himself on her and who would she tell when he did?
So yes, I suspect most, if not all of them are genuine victims, who only years later have found the strength to call him out. And it appears everyone in the industry knew about him and were either enabling him or afraid of his power.
My friend lost her job when she complained about being asked by ‘the talent’ to score him some cocaine. He’s still working.

What!? Intelligence or being street wise has nothing to do with it. It is the adult who should take responsibility, and while I’m sure there are those who play the fame game everyone should be given the benefit of doubt at a young age. I certainly remember being totally naive as a youngster, which thankfully only got me into less serious scrapes.

But it is not in law. I actually agree with the flexibility that courts have not to press charges in these sort of circumstances, but wouldn’t want it written in law.

4 Likes