We lost another one…

Ah the “who care if they all leave” brigade.

The point isn’t whether you feel sorry for wealthy people leaving, it’s whether the rest of us are better or worse off when they do.

If someone pays millions in tax, employs people, invests in businesses and spends money in the UK, losing them doesn’t punish them, it potentially leaves everyone else having to make up some of the difference.

Perhaps older people like you don’t care because you are no longer really picking up the tab..

Well, it did prompt sleazy old Depardieu to quit France and take Russian nationality…

Equally you have to recognise that in a closed economy, a billionaire who stashes his money in a hedge fund is much less use to prosperity than a bunch of “lesser” mortals who spend the money and get it circulating.

He does seem to employ 200 people which is a contribution but his net worth was estimated at $800million around 2020 and at $2 billion today. What did he do to acquire that wealth that benefitted anyone but him or his billionaire mates?

2 Likes

Do you know what a hedge fund manager does? They create no wealth :face_with_hand_over_mouth:

I pay a lot of tax in two jurisdictions. I have always paid a lot of tax. Even, believe it or not, when I was in Dubai for technical reasons I won’t bore you with.

So, I do and always have “picked up the tab”, and once the tax rate s fair I don’t mind. You are the one willing to put yourself through hoops in the name of tax avoidance and not picking up the tab. In fact, if you’re here in France and paying no tax, I am picking up your tab. That’s not too good, is it?

2 Likes

Wasn’t that more to do with his taking advantage of young actresses and it eventually becoming ‘problematic’? Or perhaps a little of both.

I doubt he’ll go through all the regulatory hoops to move them or his business overseas. Even if he does, the 200 working for him create no wealth either. Indeed, they could be destroying wealth.

If they all bugger off it’s only a PAYE hit, not of tactical or strategic importance.

1 Like

Yes, the whole picture should be looked at.
I question that if anyone who has a successful UK business, and objects to paying UK income tax and departs, would close their business?

There is a strong case for taxing multi-national companies on the business they do inside countries they are not registered in. That is businesses, not individuals of course.

It appears that Rokos made his money in clever playing of the markets. Not from giving the stable funding that does provide factories for empoyees to work in etc.
When shares in Limited Liability Companies were first introduced it was to allow wealthy individuals to invest in companies, rather than stuff mattresses with banknotes. Now those shares are being used as means to generate wealth by lightning fast trades. Companies can be shut down and people put on the dole by traders who turn a good profit by doing so.

IMHO Capitalism with rules from the Victorian era have out stayed their usefulness to society as a whole. Some still do very well from the present system, but some do not. https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/inequalities/2024/10/29/the-uks-wealth-gap-has-grown-by-50-in-eight-years./

And to be clear, I hope, I firmly believe in the old adage:
For every complex problem, there is a simple solution.
And it is always wrong.

Yep.
Give a poor man a tax cut of £1,000 and it will be spent. Give that to a thousand, and the economy has a million quid circulating.
Give a billionaire a £1m tax cut, and that is £1m he isn’t going to leverage on his next deal.

Come on boomer rabbit, it was only the other day you were complaining about inheritance tax and saying how you are avoiding it with trusts….

I will leave all mine to the goverment to help with the national debt.

And I paying habitation tax and tax Fonciere in France.

So run back down your hole you little scamp, you won’t claim any moral high ground here..

<mod>
Let’s keep it polite folks
</mod>

3 Likes

That’s not gone well for him, has it?

1 Like

Yes, you’re right, I do dislike the low thresholds for inheritance (CAT). After all, I’ve paid tax once already on the few bob I’ve managed to accumulate. It’s also particularly unfair if one has been modest in the procreation stakes. A dozen kids, a dozen TFAs, one kiddie (as in my case) one TFA :enraged_face:

On trusts, if I remember correctly, I was just outlining the options, not revealing my own mitigation strategy :face_with_hand_over_mouth:

Well that’s pointless.

And it’s a burrow or a warren, not a “hole” :slightly_smiling_face:

Every cloud… :face_with_hand_over_mouth:

No I definitely meant a hole in this case, just like Alice. :wink:

But for my final point, the whole post has focussed on this one person, when the point of it “lost another” was to highlight a trend.

The UK is becoming less and less attractive for both startups and established companies to invest in.

The FTSE is also suffering as more companies delist for the much greater liquidity of the US.

As more people leave it sends out a message to others.

From a PE perspective the UK is terrible, they basically won’t take any risks, compared to the USA. Some of the biggest US companies would have never even got off the ground in the UK.

This Labour government has no ideas, (although the Tories also ran out of them a long time ago) how to get growth, in fact they have halted any chance of it.

The people who can make it happen are leaving in droves. The new chief bus conductor in command hasn’t presented anything but slogans yet. “Growth in every postcode”. But let’s see what the October budget brings…

The UK is sliding down rapidly, Boomers have no need to worry, other generations do.

Click on 5 years. Looking better over the last 24 months than the 24 months beforehand. And that is with the turbulence caused in all markets by Trump.

Deregulation might mean faster growth for some. It has repeatedly seen bubbles and collapses.
That lesson has to be repeatedly “learnt” time after time.

Really? How many? What are your sources for that?

Since we shot ourselves in the foot over Brexit, yes we could/should have been in a better place now. But we did cock up and we are here now.

1 Like

I think that came to light much later - post-COVID?

That is confusing the current value of the FTSE vs it’s attractiveness for companies to list on it.

The FTSE is the 100 largest qualifying companies. If one company leaves, another company simply moves into its place.

It can keep rising even while the overall London listed market becomes smaller and loses some of its most successful companies.

100%! But we can’t keep blaming that unless the goverment is prepared to change it.

Boomers have children and grandchildren. Their economic wellbeing is a major worry. Everyone on here would like to see the UK economy turn the corner. The fastest and surest way to do that IMO is closer alignment with the Single Market. There’s low hanging GDP %s to be grabbed.

You are correct that investment money is scarce in the UK compared to the US. But I believe that is a risk adverse cultural issue. So tough to change. I have never seen any correlation between FDI (foreign direct investment) and personal taxation rates (maybe you have, I’m always willing to learn) Apart perhaps from foreign executives being reluctant to relocate or come on assignment. Which is trivial issue for a company to resolve. And remember, US citizens are taxed on WW income anyway no matter where they reside.

So, in conclusion, if all the hedge managers (who, once again, just shuffle paper and create no wealth) in London pissed off to zero income tax Bongo Bongo land, there would IMHO be SFA negative impact on the man on the Clapham Omnibus. In fact maybe housing availability and prices might improve a bit :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

Come on, you can’t use an advertisement as a source :joy: I guess they’ve got you hook, line and sinker though :slightly_frowning_face:

“Rathbones who analysed Companies House filings from between January 2024 and 2026, of the business owners who have left the UK, the greatest number work in the technology sector.”

So you are saying it’s not true?

If so what are you basing that on exactly?

Agreed!