“We lost another one…” hour, reading through this thread
when we could have just said immediately ‘exit tax’ … just like France has.
“We lost another one…” hour, reading through this thread
when we could have just said immediately ‘exit tax’ … just like France has.
Yes already been done. Those who wanted to and had the means have avoided tax attack fron that angle for many decades.
On the other hand if you have fixed assets and are only ordinary, particularly in F but also in the UK, as you can’t move that type of asset easily which is exactly your point, the taxman has you in his claws.
The game has moved on and wealth is held differently now and the paths to much ownership still easy enough to obscure if you have enough means.
@Larkswood12 France has an exit tax?
Sitting here in France, I’m having a hollow laugh about how anti-new business Moulin de Sarlat is saying the UK is. Compared to France, the UK is nirvana especially for small to medium business.
France is not productive enough in comparison to what it costs to fund the expectations of the population. Hence capital grabs such as on inheritance and stonking CGT aka eating their own flesh. As capital is needed for business and investment. And don’t get me started on the admin burden and social tax affecting smaller businesses. To the point so many die as there is no resource left when circumstances throw up the odd difficulty. The practical relatively free culture of the UK has a much better chance of nurturing a business rather than sucking the life out of it.
So Rathbones looked at companies who have left the FTSE 100 since Labour were elected and have decide it is because Reeves moved in to No 11?
Surely one should look at a longer data set to see what effect Labour was having? Look at pre and post election figures.
The Telegraph talks of a much longer trend.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/08/07/how-ftse-became-a-departure-lounge-for-british-companies/
City AM talks of foreign money buying out UK FTSE 100 companies
And none of that negates the point I was trying to make: The FT 250 has been climbing for about 2 years. The election of Labour has not shown a dip.
In fact given the election of Trump it is rather surprising that we haven’t seen a slump! Well, not quite yet anyway.
Fingers crossed.
Touch wood.
Yep. I think it is quite well known that many French go to the UK in order to start up businesses that are not location dependent isn’t it?
That hasn’t changed for the worse recently.
You absolutely nailed it Karen!’ ![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
You perfectly described what happens to a country when they go too far with taxes, and with a real world example, basically being anti business, .
All you needed to add, is it that didn’t happen overnight.
I rest my case.
Yes absolutely, and as I say the Tories had already run out of ideas, well before they were kicked out, and growth has been stagnant for years.
It’s just that after shooting ourselves in the foot with Brexit, it seems Labour think we should amputate the legs too..
In the current global situation (cough! Trump) what are Labour doing wrong?
I know you don’t like proposed increased taxes for the wealthest, but where is that actually doing the UK economy as a whole harm? I still can’t see it.
You started with a one off example of one very rich individual leaving. I don’t think you have shown that as a significant trend.
All economics is about interpreting causes and effects of many interlocking things. For my money(!) Labour policies have been every bit as successful as Tory policies for the UK over the years.
Look at GDP per capita (I suggest that as about the simplest measure of a country’s economic success) against the party in power. That needs to be taken against the global background of course.
It ain’t easy to tease it out, but when you say the Tories recently ran out of ideas, I say their ideas were never much good for the country at any time over the past 50 years. They came up with such short term wheezes as “selling off the family silver” (McMillan on Thatcher) which made some richer, but the country worse off.
Labour are far, far, from perfect, but seem to be every bit as competent at macro economics as any Tory for over half a century.
+±+±+±
The capitalism that has served the UK, and the West generally very well is going to need a serious rethink very soon. Automation of labour and of “thought” will probably see some real upheaval soon.
Citing the industrial revolution as giving more wealth for all (some more than others) is not going to cut it. One instance does not make a trend!
If I can’t convince you why brain drain is a bad thing then fair enough, I won’t continue to try.
But employer NI hikes… nobody can say that is a good thing.
Are you conflating the “brain drain” with flight of the wealthy? Not at all the same thing.
You yourself recognise that the UK is friendlier to start ups than France is don’t you?
How many of the cutting edge science and tech brains are wealthy enough to be caught out?
What getting more money into the exchequer for the NHS and state pensions etc? More money for defence?
No one much likes seeig their personal bottom line reduced, but surely in the real world we recognise that is a society we all need to cough up something.
And one way and another we have been getting wth paying too little. Now, I fully accept that where the burden falls is not at all clear cut.
Cut or limit Employer NI? Fine. So where else should the shortfall come from? You already have said you don’t want the wealthiest paying more tax. You don’t like property tax. Should inheritance tax be 90 or 100%? How much would that raise? I don’t know.
IMO, inheritance tax should be 33% on every single pound for every single person, no trusts, everybody should pay it, whether you are a king or a duke or the man on the street.
People talk about the rich hoarding wealth, that is exactly what inheritance is.
People say the money has already been taxed, it hasn’t because the dead can’t pay tax, it’s the person receiving it who is paying it, and they didn’t earn it.
But in general the goverment need to look past more and more tax, it’s a dead end road.
They also need to find a way to get half the country back to work, with both carrot and stick. Whether that is cutting benefits or providing opportunities for young people. Raising NI was not good for youth employment.
And like I said brain drain has never worked…
The guy who writes the code isn’t typically the guy who starts the company and creates the wealth.
Agree.
All (most) purchases we make are with money that has already been taxed as income. The double taxation argument is woffle.
Totally agree.
We do need those who use “exploit” the invention of the brains. Without them taking a disproportionate reward for themselves.
Reward the inventors and Doctors in this world not the money makers
It’a risk versus reward, quite often the guy who is writing the code at the start is getting a salary, he isn’t taking any risk, the founder is.
Having said that all early employees typically do very well through share options.
Anthropic’s upcoming public listing is projected to turn virtually all of its estimated 4000-5000 employees into millionaires or multi-millionaires!
Incredible!
taking a disproportionate reward for themselves.
Nothing wrong with taking a.disproportionate slice, they may have risked everything to make it. Once that level gets way over any reasonable level, the sort of income made by large cities or small countries then its time to pay your way. However for many the affliction of self takes over with shear greed.
It’a risk versus reward,
Yes. Gambling.
That is why the Victorians invented the limited liability company system. To allow investment without individuals losing all.
Of course the idea of that was to allow investment in factories and plant etc. And to risk exploration.
In 1855 the concept of electronic trading of stocks/shares/futures was hardly even a Holmesian pipe-dream. And to return to the top of this thread, Rokos has not been investing in factories, he has been speculating: gambling.
If someone chooses to risk all? Don’t worry, the rest of us will ensure they will not starve. That is how society works.
Having said that all early employees typically do very well through share options.
Only for the successful companies of course. The few that make headlines.
The many who fold in obscurity do not.
Only for the successful companies of course. The few that make headlines.
The many who fold in obscurity do not.
And those employees who were getting a salary are free to go and get another salaried job.
Everybody has the freedom to choose what they do (within reason).
I’m still trying to overcome the devastating news that there is no such thing as economic trickle down ![]()